On Wednesday, February 28, deputies proposed introducing criminal liability for health workers who, through negligence, replaced children in maternity hospitals. The bill provides for punishment of up to five years in prison and a fine of 200 thousand rubles. The idea came about after two elderly women decided to sue the maternity hospital over a mistake that happened almost 40 years ago. In 1978, during discharge from the maternity ward, obstetricians mixed up newborn girls. All this time, families raised other people's children as their own, and now they are preparing lawsuits. One of the mothers recognized that the child had been switched even when she took the baby in her arms for the first time, but she managed to get to the bottom of the truth only many years later. The history of these families resembles the plot of a melodrama, however, such cases began to be revealed more and more often in different regions countries. Medical negligence has caused discord in families and created mistrust between parents for years. The portal site found out how the fates of children who were mixed up in maternity hospitals turned out.
It's like you've been replaced
From the very beginning, Rimma Shvetsova suspected that she was raising someone else’s child: the fair-haired, blue-eyed girl did not look like anyone in the household. When Veronica was born, the family already had two children, another one - a boy - was born a few years later. As she grew older, the difference between her and her sisters and brother became more and more noticeable. In addition to external differences, the baby had a different blood type. The father of the family did not like the girl and was sure that the daughter was from another man. Due to constant reproaches, the family fell apart: the husband found another woman and filed for divorce. And Rimma was left alone with four children in her arms.
Shvetsova remembered very well that on the day of birth, in addition to her, there were three other women in the department. Among them was Yulia Savelyeva, to whom they gave the brown-eyed girl. None of the children had tags on their arms. Tatyana, who grew up in the Savelyev family, on the contrary, was a favorite child. Although problematic: other children were afraid of her. Almost no attention was paid to her difference from her parents.
The families first met when the girls were less than one year old. Rimma Shvetsova came to visit the Savelyevs and shared her suspicion that the children had been replaced.
“Rimma Pavlovna came to us with Veronica and said that our children were changed, apparently in the maternity hospital, that her husband didn’t like her daughter, that she didn’t look like them,” Yulia Savelyeva told ProPerm. - But I didn’t give my Tanya away, of course. My husband loves children. And how can I give my child away, she’s already so big, she’s smiling. No, I won't give it away. And it was hard for me to believe that doctors could do this - change our children.”
In addition, the possibility of doing a DNA examination and proving medical error Women didn't have it back then. Even in the early 2000s, DNA tests were expensive and only performed in major cities. In a small village in Perm region it was impossible to do anything like that.
Almost 40 years later, Shvetsova turned to the “Let Them Talk” program and told her story. Child switching is one of the favorite plots of Russian TV shows. The editors of the TV show invited parents and their grown-up daughters to the studio. And it was there that the results of the DNA test were announced: the probability of a match was 99%.
“For the first time in my life, I was confused,” Rimma Pavlovna shared her impressions. “I have been through so much, endured so much, I never expected anything from the state and never asked for anything. I was confused, offended and very angry at our medicine.”
It was she who first decided to file a claim with the regional Ministry of Health. It will not be possible to hold doctors accountable. Limitation periods for criminal liability medical workers have long expired. If we consider that the girls were born 40 years ago, then obstetricians may no longer be alive. By material damage The term is only three years, but for moral damage it is completely absent.
“Since each person individually experienced moral suffering because of this story, the lawsuits will not be collective. Rimma Shvetsova is already preparing a lawsuit, Yulia Savelyeva too. According to judicial practice, you can count on about a million rubles,” lawyer Igor Savvin, who represents the interests of the victims in court, explains to the website portal.
Fathers can also be considered victims in this situation. Especially considering the fact that the replacement of a child in the maternity hospital served as the basis for mistrust and family breakdown. “The Shvetsovs’ husband started drinking heavily because of this. He had a stroke a few years ago and is having difficulty communicating. But he has every right to go to court,” Savvin added.
It is quite possible to sue for compensation, Savvin is sure. Moreover, four families who found themselves in similar circumstances have already succeeded.
Chelyabinsk Zita and Gita
A high-profile incident occurred in Chelyabinsk region in the summer of 2017. Zoya Tuganova proved that she raised and educated someone else’s daughter. Due to an error by obstetricians, the Russian girl was raised in a Bashkir family, and the Bashkir girl in a Russian one.
Even during discharge, Tuganova realized that this was not her child, but the doctors threatened the mother with a psychiatric examination and forced her to accept someone else’s baby. While the dark-skinned girl, named Katya, grew up in a prosperous family, her own daughter Lucia languished in poverty.
The father who raised her suspected his wife of infidelity due to the birth of a girl, began drinking heavily, and then went to prison for murder. At the age of 13, Lucia was sent to Orphanage. Tuganova found her own daughter 30 years later on social networks: she remembered the name of the woman in labor from the next ward, to whom, as it seemed to her, her girl could be given. Lucia lived very poorly, became disabled and raised three children.
Only one of the mothers, Tuganova, went to court and won the lawsuit. Tuligenova was no longer alive at that time. The victim demanded 10 million for replacing the children, but received 1 million rubles. She considered the amount too small to cover the damage caused.
“If the children had not been mixed up, my own daughter would have grown up in love and would not have ended up in an orphanage. I'm 70 years old now. At this age, I can no longer help her financially. I live on one pension. The mistake that doctors made costs much more,” Tuganova told KP Chelyabinsk.
I won’t give up what’s mine, I won’t give up someone else’s
In all four cases of child substitution, the court sided with the victims. IN Oryol region It was even possible to punish the perpetrators. In 2009, hearings were held about the replacement of two babies - Nikita and Adlan. The parents learned about the nurse’s mistake two years later: the mother of one of the boys, Anna Androsova, discovered a different name on back side newborn tags - Zarema Taisumova.
Then she contacted the Chechen family, but they flatly refused to give up blue-eyed Adlan. At that time, the boy had already become like family to them. The Taisumov family was preparing to move to Grozny; it never occurred to them that the child they were raising could be replaced.
The Androsovs went to court, a DNA examination was ordered, which showed that, due to an error, a Chechen boy was raised in the Androsov family, and a Russian boy with a severe congenital defect was raised in the Taisumov family. After the test, the children were returned to their families. The court awarded the mother of each child 150 thousand rubles. The midwife who admitted fatal mistake while swaddling children, fired. The families were denied the opportunity to initiate a criminal case into the substitution of babies.
The “buried” one was returned
Events developed no less dramatically in Volgograd, where the mother was returned to her son, who, due to a medical error, was listed as dead for seven years. The parents learned that their son was actually alive from the bailiffs, who sent them a document on the collection of alimony. Not finding the family at home, the FSSP seized the money in the mother’s account. The debt amounted to 230 thousand rubles. When the woman came to the department to investigate, she was informed that her son, whom they considered dead, had been in the orphanage all this time.
“Looking at the documents, the parent fainted. And after bringing her to her senses, it turned out that the couple was sure all this time that the child had died,” the service department for the Volgograd region said in a statement.
The boy was born in 2011, and doctors gave him a few days. The young parents wrote a refusal to give up their child, but a few days later they changed their minds and returned to pick him up. Then doctors stated that the child did not survive.
On New Year's Eve, the family went to court to restore parental rights and celebrated the holiday in full force. However, they did not seek compensation for childhood spent without parents due to someone else’s oversight. On the contrary, they paid alimony for the maintenance of the child whom they “buried” and mourned.
“The parents were very frightened by the public outcry that their story caused, I had to reassure them. They asked me not to disclose their personal information, and I promised them this on my part. This is a prosperous family, they still have two children; in 2017, their parental rights were restored in relation to their disabled son. I don’t have any concerns for the child who was returned to the family,” said Nina Boldyreva, Commissioner for Children’s Rights in the Volgograd Region.
She considers this story to be fiction and refuses to believe that the child could be declared dead and sent to an orphanage. According to her, already in those years active work was carried out to prevent social orphanhood and doctors simply could not allow this to happen.
Continuation of the issue Let them say - A mistake in the maternity hospital. On this broadcast, you watched an amazing life story about how 34 years ago, in a maternity hospital in a Buryat village, newborn girls - Yulia and Dugarma - were changed. Yesterday this terrible error was corrected in the program. One of the heroines of the broadcast, Honored Artist of Buryatia Alisa Tsyrenova, became convinced that all this time she was raising someone else’s child. However, today she and the other participants in the issue will be no less shocked... Watch Let them talk - Mistake in the maternity hospital Part 2 02/07/2017
But before you learn new details of the broadcast, it’s worth remembering what happened: on January 21, 1983, Alisa Tsyrenova gave birth to a daughter early in the morning in the village of Kurumkan (Republic of Buryatia). A few hours later, in the same maternity hospital there was a woman named Lyubov, who also gave birth to a daughter. Later long years each of the women learned that her own daughter lived in another family. It became clear that the newborn girls were switched that day in the maternity hospital. The results of the DNA test in the last issue dotted all the i's and, it would seem, there are no more secrets. But then other shocking details are revealed!
Let them talk - Mistake in the maternity hospital Part 2
In the studio of the “Let Them Talk” program, Yulia Tsyrenova’s aunt is Tsytsyk Putushkina, who suggests that her sister Alisa...was also mixed up in the maternity hospital!
“It’s not easy for my sister Alice now.” We had no doubt at all that Yulia was our blood, our niece. Now we have another niece - Dagurma and we will love her too. Of course, neither we nor Yulia’s parents are to blame for this.
— Once, when I was 23 years old, there was my cousin’s wedding. I was a friend there, and an unfamiliar woman approached me and said that Alice was her own daughter!
All traces lead to the maternity hospital
On the Let Them Talk program (episode Error in the Maternity Hospital Part 2 dated 02/07/2017), the results of a DNA test for the relationship of two sisters: Alisa and Tsytsyk were announced. The news shocked everyone present in the studio: Alice was not Native sister Tsytsyk! Moreover, Alisa Tsyrenova was born...in the same maternity hospital in the village of Kurumkan as her daughter and Lyuba’s daughter!
But that’s not all: another DNA test was carried out to determine the kinship of other women from Buryatia invited to the program, one of whom was born in the same maternity hospital: Tatiana and Butidma. Surprisingly, they are not sisters either.
New, fresh releases
Exclusive
Dramatic moments
The author is burning
Episodes with stars
2016-2017 season
2015-2016 season
In the middle of the party Part 1
In the midst of the party Continued Part 2
In the midst of the party Continued Part 3
#Nadonyshke: How Diana Shurygina became an Internet star Part 4
#Nadonyshke: How Diana Shurygina became an Internet star Part 5
Everyone is crazy about Svetlana Loboda
Mother 50/50
34-year-old grandmother deprived of maternal rights
Hitting a child in Priozersk
Our Julia! Eurovision 2017 participant Yulia Samoilova
Shame on our family!
Mortgage slavery
Candid story captives of the Skopinsky maniac
Murder in the line of duty
I endured
Flash of jealousy
In what century was Pushkin born?
#Fatboy
Checkmate mother
Let's goodbye!
Tragedy over Lake Constance 15 years later
The star of “The Inhabited Island” Vasily Stepanov fell out of the window
Somersault in bed
Love from all the cracks
Mom can
Dads or sugar daddies?
Danka's Heart: Is Dana Borisova a drug addict?
The whole village
Heart of Danka-2: did Dana Borisova agree to be treated for drug addiction?
Dad is burning
Daughter for 50 thousand dollars
Becoming a mother after retirement
Patients against plastic surgeon
Dana Borisova is deprived of parental rights
The mystery of Lisa Tishkina
Shurik In memory of Alexander Demyanenko
Ivan's childhood
Get to the truth
Cling to the glory
ex-fiancee Is Prokhora Chaliapin expecting a baby?
Childhood burns
Tragedy on six hundred square meters - nine corpses and one survivor
Husband and wife, one of Satan
Kratovo shooter
Panic horror: Alexey Panin is again at the center of a scandal
In memory of the great Batalov Last interview
Friske and Shepelev Actually, Who stole millions of rubles?
Boomerang of Ilona Novoselova’s curses: what killed the psychic?
Dana Borisova interrupted treatment in a Thai drug clinic
The father of the “drunk boy” disputes the results of the examination
Nicole's last birthday
Sensation: how Voronenkov was really killed
New examination results
Evil Rock
“Why save if he’s going to die anyway”: a glamorous official fired for heartlessness
The baby is disconnected from the devices
Oliver Stone: what Putin's voice sounds like
“My dad is cooler!”
Maksakova and Voronenkov: the “elimination” operation continues
The Posthumous Story of a Drunk Boy
Dad from Panama for a TV star
Secrets of the personal life of Vladimir Basov
Alicia Calista James found her father
Star baby boom 2017
The biggest boy in Russia wants to lose weight!
How Russian oligarchs rock out. Exclusive interview Robbie Williams
The main intrigue of the summer: who will replace Andrei Malakhov in “Let Them Talk”?
Alone with Saakashvili: elite masseuse Dorothy
star fever Evgenia Osina:
To the ends of the world Lightning: Vera Glagoleva died
Unforgivable beauty: response to Maria Maksakova
Crime and torture
The hunt for the champion, why Andrei Drachev was killed
Sensational twist in the “drunk boy” case
Volochkova and the disgraced favorite
Poison Volochkova
Murder in Gorky Park
Diana's last will
Blood of the Chief
I came here to die
Divorce from mother-in-law
Battle for Boris Nemtsov's millions
You didn't believe me, and I died
American woman demands exhumation of Ilya Glazunov's ashes
Scam of the century: HIV dissidents reveal their faces
A Voice for All Seasons: The Hidden Secrets of Igor Kirillov
Bad education school teacher beat up a child
Vadim Kazachenko bigamist
Alexander Novikov and deceived fans
The point in the Alyosha Shimko case: was the “drunk boy” drunk?
Abandoned son famous actress Evdokia Germanova
If tomorrow is the end of the world
Ural “Angelina Jolie”, children were taken away from a woman who had her breasts removed
Why is my son red? Valya Isaeva's husband demands DNA
Stardust forgotten children famous actor
Russian family of Fidel Castro
Film Crimea discussion
Spartak Mishulin has a son
Maksakova accuses Tyurin of Voronenkov’s murder
Miracle workers?
Thai prisoner: Evgeniy Osin escaped from the clinic
Vadimovichi is another family of bigamist Kazachenko
Under the microscope: revelations from an expert in the case of a drunken boy
Armen Dzhigarkhanyan torn between wives
Died or killed? Details of the death of Dmitry Maryanov
Dzhigarkhanyan and his Vitalina: a thriller with an open ending
Like me
Secrets of the Phoenix Clinic Dmitry Maryanov, who is next?: from 10/30/2017
Anisina introduces Dzhigurda to her lover. Issue dated 10/31/2017
Oligarch DNA: millions for an illegitimate daughter. Issue dated 11/01/2017
The return of Kashpirovsky: a new television show. Issue dated 02.11.2017
The heart of Vadim Kazachenko: a heart attack for every wife. Issue dated 11/07/2017
How love dies. Issue dated 11/08/2017
Maxim Galkin about the life and death of Mikhail Zadornov
In the new house Confession of Armen Dzhigarkhanyan
Is Dmitry Maryanov still killed? Eyewitness accounts
Exclusive interview from behind bars
Is Spartak Mishulin still my dad?
DNA test for the probable son of Spartak Mishulin
Mishulin's handwriting how many children does he have? people's artist
Divorce the star
Love Factory secret marriage of Sati Casanova
Bitter letters famous husband
In memory of Hvorostovsky: the bright knight who conquered darkness
Confession of Vasily Shukshin's first wife
The most expensive medicine in the world: how donors are made from children
Divorce of the year: Is Vitalina pregnant?
Vitalina's rich plans
Mishulin's legacy: son or not son? DNA test result
Dzhigarkhanyan's heir: exclusive from Las Vegas
Dzhigarkhanyan's will: a new version
Children of Spartak: how to reconcile Karina and Timur?
12/11/2017 - In memory of Leonid Bronevoy
12.12.2017 - The pianist started a criminal case against Vitalina
12/14/2017 - Author is burning
12/15/2017 - From Maryanov to Lyadov
12/18/2017 - The oligarch and the rich countess are also crying
12/19/2017 - American daughter of Alexander Malinin is wanted
12/20/2017 - What will Evstigneev’s last wife get as a widow’s share?
12/21/2017 - Kremlin stars of Vladimir Berezin
12/25/2017 - 18 years later Dzhigarkhanyan called his son
12/26/2017 - Goodwill of Dzhigarkhanyan
12/27/2017 - Escape from the golden cage
12/28/2017 - Spartak Mishulin’s secret message to children
09.01.2018 - Last Confession: Brezhnev's granddaughter died
01/10/2018 - Mikhail Derzhavin: last interview
01/11/2018 - Hour of reckoning: the curse of the Brezhnev clan
01/15/2018 - Diana Shurygina is shocked by the release of the rapist
01/16/2018 - The ghost of Vitalina in the new life of Dzhigarkhanyan
17.01.2018 - Ex-wife Dzhigarkhanyana presents Vitalina with her account
01/18/2018 - Last hope: miracles on the eve of Epiphany
01/22/2018 - Stolen DNA: the star’s inheritance is under threat
01/23/2018 - Daughter versus star brother results of a new DNA test
01/24/2018 - Brezhnev’s great-granddaughter is on the trail of lost treasures
01/25/2018 - Special issue: the tragic death of Lyudmila Senchina
01/25/2018 - Vladimir Vysotsky last love
01/29/2018 - Vitalina’s repentance
01/30/2018 - Honor of the Dzhigarkhanyan family, the meeting that Vitalina is looking for
01/31/2018 - Author laughs
01.02.2018 - Free man: Armen Dzhigarkhanyan got divorced
02/05/2018 - Dzhigarkhanyan’s two wives face to face
02/06/2018 - Battle for the love of Armen Dzhigarkhanyan
02/07/2018 - Sensational DNA test of the unrecognized heiress of the star
02/08/2018 - Irina Khakamada about the fate of her daughter
02/12/2018 - Will of Lyudmila Gurchenko
02/13/2018 - Another former mother-in-law of Dzhigarkhanyan
02/14/2018 - Who sold Dzhigarkhanyan’s apartment and to whom?
02/15/2018 - Love and tears of daughters Alexander Serova
02/19/2018 - “You are my sister”: Timur Eremeev responds to Karina Mishulina
02/20/2018 - “Karina, take heart!” New witnesses - about the life of Spartak Mishulin
02/21/2018 - Maxim Galkin: “I will tell the truth under hypnosis”
02/26/2018 - Serov responds to exes and illegitimate ones
02/27/2018 - Special issue: meeting our Olympians.
02/28/2018 - Stolen happiness, two mothers of one child went to jail
03/01/2018 - The double life of Spartak Mishulin
05.03.2018 - Secret life Dzhigarkhanyan and Vitalina after the divorce
03/06/2018 - Mishulin’s diaries that helped Timur win the trial
03/12/2018 - The untold drama of Dmitry Maryanov
03/13/2018 - Oleg Tabakov died
03/14/2018 - Half a century later, new adventures Elusive Avengers
15.03.2018 - Unknown daughter Gypsy Yashki
03/19/2018 - Olga Korbut's loop
03/20/2018 - In the footsteps of Skripal
03/21/2018 - Alesya Kafelnikova
03/22/2018 - Dzhigarkhanyan strikes back
03.26.2018 - Kemerovo, we are with you
03/28/2018 - Fire in Winter Cherry
03/29/2018 - Long last way?
04/02/2018 - Father or donor Vadim Kazachenko
04/03/2018 - The whole truth of Olga Korbut
04/04/2018 - Relatives are waiting to meet Yulia Skripal
05.04.2018 - School Romance new Valya Isaeva takes a DNA test
04/09/2018 - Victoria Skripal: Yulia cried when I spoke to her
04/10/2018 - Fateeva and Kustinskaya
04/11/2018 - Chemical attacks from Litvinenko to Skripal and the Duma
04/12/2018 - Scotland Yard speaks for Yulia Skripal
04/16/2018 - Armen Dzhigarkhanyan and Vitalina are together again?
04/17/2018 - Karina vs Timur: Session with exposure
04/18/2018 - Example of the son of Spartak Mishulin
04/19/2018 - Gone with the wind: The first Russian millionaires have passed away
04/23/2018 - In memory of Nina Doroshina: Love, doves and broken heart
04/24/2018 - Lone Wolf: A pop star on the brink of life and death
04/25/2018 - Call to Dzhigarkhanyan: Is Vitalina facing prison?
04/26/2018 - Phantoms and fakes in the case of the children of Spartak Mishulin
04/27/2018 - Lifelong dream: Yulia Samoilova conquers Eurovision
05/03/2018 - The fate of Dzhigarkhanyan
05/07/2018 - The Path to Victory
05/08/2018 - The Age of Dictator Balashov: War Hero - for the first time about personal
05/10/2018 - Vitalina for Ivan Krasko: Family drama people's artist
05/14/2018 - “No need to frown, Lada!” American tragedy of the Soviet idol
05.15.2018 - Couldn’t hold back my tears: Vitalina saw Dzhigarkhanyan
16.05.2018 - New Vanga predicts the future
05/17/2018 - The secret will of Tamara Nosova
21.05.2018 New mystery Sergei Skripal
05/22/2018 The young singer identified himself as the son of Muslim Magomayev
05/23/2018 New witness in the case of Spartak Mishulin
05/24/2018 Yulia Skripal answers Let them talk
28.05.2018 Unequal marriage Mikhail Pugovkina
05/29/2018 Big secret Soviet actress Zoe Fedorova
05/30/2018 Far from everyone Tamara Chernova
05/31/2018 Did a Russian beauty give birth to a star football player?
06/04/2018 Revenge of the ex club
06.06.2018 Kazachenko vs. Kazachenko
06/07/2018 How “Direct Line” changes lives
06/08/2018 Will of Tamara Nosova
06/13/2018 Behind the hospital door
06/14/2018 First emotions after the match Russia - Saudi Arabia
06/18/2018 A pop star in his declining years: a chronicle of betrayed trust
06/19/2018 Who are Batalov’s widow and daughter afraid of?
06/20/2018 How Allegrova and Dolina left their husbands
06/21/2018 The great and the lonely: the price to pay for success?
06/25/2018 Special issue. Russia - Uruguay
06/26/2018 Sensation in the Kazachenko case: Sanity test
06.27.2018 Who asked you to give birth
06/28/2018 Two truths of Elena Ksenofontova
07/02/2018 Classified as “secret”: Was Zoya Fedorova killed by her American son-in-law?
07/03/2018 Special issue: We believe in our preparations for the quarterfinals
07/04/2018 Eremeev case
07/05/2018 Sensational call: the key to solving the “Skripal case”?
07/06/2018 1 Special issue
07/07/2018 2 Special issue
07/09/2018 Secret examination of Karina Mishulina
07/10/2018 Elena Proklova last chance to be happy
07/11/2018 Forbidden novel by Leonid Engibarov
07/12/2018 Old age can wait
07/16/2018 The last grandson left, Andrei Brezhnev/option> died
07/17/2018 Secrets of football wives
07/18/2018 Wives of great people fight for the lives of their husbands
07/19/2018 Biohackers: how to hack the aging program
07/23/2018 Diamond trail in the murder of Zoya Fedorova
07/24/2018 Thriller of the era: Diamond dust of the Brezhnev clan
07/25/2018 Meeting of two fathers Vladislav Galkin
07/26/2018 Sergei Skripal’s mother waited for a call from England
07/30/2018 Divorce of Vadim Kazachenko
07/31/2018 In front of everyone: she starved an excellent student to death birth mother
08/01/2018 Valentina Leontyeva’s son: “All about mom”
02.08.2018 A little prince
06.08.2018 Poor and rich
08/07/2018 Confused in the maternity hospital DNA test
08.08.2018 Difficult Gaft
08/09/2018 Dzhigurda’s killer arguments
08/13/2018 What happened in the family of singer Danko
08/14/2018 Tied children
08/15/2018 Eduard Uspensky died
08/16/2018 American trap
08/20/2018 Parents meet with the owners of the kindergarten
08/21/2018 Why the bald model was beaten
08/22/2018 Who killed Zoya Fedorova
08/22/2018 Divorce of Petrosyan and Stepanenko
08/23/2018 Hvorostovsky's will
08/27/2018 Karina Mishulina’s secret trump card
08/28/2018 Roman Zhukov’s retaliatory strike
08/29/2018 Who killed Zoya Fedorova
08/30/2018 In memory of Joseph Kobzon
08/31/2018 Zoya Fedorova’s grandson achieved the truth
09/3/2018 Ivan Krasko about the reasons for the divorce
09/04/2018 Zoya Fedorova’s grandson achieved the truth
5.09.2018 Eldest daughter Sergei Lemokh begs for help
6.09.2018 Secret marriage Lyudmila Ryumina
09/10/2018 The mystery of blood
09/11/2018 Edita Piekha’s large family
09/12/2018 The story of the queen of shocking
09/13/2018 Whom did Elina Mazur try to kill?
09/17/2018 Petrosyan and Stepanenko
09/18/2018 Bloodhound DNA
09/19/2018 What separated Stepanenko and Petrosyan
09.20.2018 You have been ordered
09.24.2018 Daughter of Eduard Uspensky about her father’s will
09.25.2018 Luxurious life and hungry children of Kirill Emelyanov
09.26.2018 Labor veteran convicted of poppy in garden
09/27/2018 Confession of the wife of General Romanov
10/1/2018 The Khachaturian sisters were released from prison
10/2/2018 Who will get all the property of the Khachaturian family
3.10.2018 We see off Roman Kartsev
10/4/2018 Alexander Serov the whole truth about the scandal with Friends
10/8/2018 Weight 17 kilograms
10/9/2018 Was Zoya Fedorova killed during a conversation with another actress?
10.10.2018 Red card for Kokorin and Mamaev
10/11/2018 What Natalya Krachkovskaya knew about the murder of Zoya Fedorova
10.15.2018 Imaginary daughter and last love of Olga Voronets
10/16/2018 Exorbitant weight
10/17/2018 For the sake of truth - across the ocean: DNA test 20 years later
10/18/2018 Tragedy in Kerch
10.19.2018 Devoted twice
10/22/2018 The lead singer of the group Masha and the Bears was beaten
10/23/2018 (Repeat 10/17/2018) Divorce Krasko
10/24/2018 Save Svetlana Morgunova
10.25.2018 Svetlana’s mother suicide note Stalin's wives
10/29/2018 The owner of the Rublevsky mansion against Elina Mazur
10/30/2018 Deception revealed: The last secret Victoria Fedorova
10/31/2018 Official's mistress
1.11.2018 Sami Naseri was beaten and given a ride
11/6/2018 Anisina secretly flew to Dzhigurda
11/7/2018 Timur Eremeev; "Mishulin is my father, and Karina is not my sister"
8.11.2018 Operation "Hoax" Karina responds to Timur
9.11.2018 Daughter Soviet Union
11/12/2018 New illegitimate daughter Alexandra Serova
11/13/2018 Restricted American daughter of Alexander Malinin
11/14/2018 Star diaries of the fight against cancer
11/15/2018 Confession of Vadim Kazachenko
11/19/2018 Secret conversations of Alexander Serov and his women
11/19/2018 He lost his battle with alcohol
11/20/2018 (repeat) Secret conversations of Alexander Serov and his women
11.21.2018 Resolution of the drama of another daughter of Serov
11/22/2018 Wedding of the year
11/26/2018 Even if you die, I won’t give you medicine!
11/27/2018 Vadim Kazachenko’s two wives learn about the third
11/28/2018 Fight for Kazachenko
29.11.2018 New wedding Alibasova came as a shock to his wife
3.12.2018 Mysterious death Yuri Kovelenov
12/4/2018 Shot in the face
12/5/2018 Who threatens Karachentsov’s mistress
12/6/2018 The heir of Khoper-invest undergoes a DNA test
12/10/2018 Daria Ermolaeva declared war on her stepmother
12/11/2018 Married to Alibasov
12/12/2018 Who created the Cashbury pyramid
12/13/2018 At the deathbed
12/17/2018 Nikolay Noskov about himself terrible day life
12/18/2018 (repeat) Daughter of the Soviet Union
12/19/2018 Elena Solovey far from her homeland
12/20/2018 Daughter and son of Vladimir Vysotsky?
12/24/2018 Shukshina’s daughters against the newlywed Alibasov
12/25/2018 The rock woman meets her parents
12/26/2018 Relatives how they divide Mordyukova’s inheritance
12/27/2018 Svetlana Alekseeva finds her mother
01/09/2019 Alexander Golovin does not recognize his daughter and demands a DNA test
01/10/2019 Descendant of Rasputin historical DNA test
01/14/2019 Anna Shukshina
01/15/2019 Daughter and granddaughter of Lidia Fedoseeva Shukshina
01/16/2019 Did the beauty queen cheat on her husband right at the competition?
01/17/2019 Shocking confessions of Agafya Lykova
01/21/2019 Are relatives heirs or beggars for Mordyukova?
01/22/2019 Alexander Golovin’s lover was kicked out of the house
01/23/2019 Last interview with Chris Kelmi
01/24/2019 Vysotsky’s son about his father
01/28/2019 Death on credit
01/29/2019 Why does Volochkova run away to the Maldives?
01/30/2019 Theft of the century
01/31/2019 Appeal to the star sister of Evelina Bledans
02/04/2019 Decl’s last concert
02/05/2019 Star against Maryanov’s widow
02/06/2019 “It was murder!”: ex-love Dmitry Maryanov - about the death of the father of his child
02/07/2019 Another muse of Alexander Abdulov
02/11/2019 New investigation into the deaths of tourists at the Dyatlov Pass
02/12/2019 I know the secret of the Dyatlov Pass
02/13/2019 Ivan Krasko finds out the truth about ex-wives
02/14/2019 Vasily Shukshin Jr.
02/18/2019 Grandchildren of Lidia Fedoseeva Shukshina
02/19/2019 Withdraw to clean water: Shukshin's grandchildren against "Family Enemies"
02/20/2019 The dramatic fate of Sergei Zakharov
02/21/2019 Dangerous millions: Elena Dmitrieva asks for protection
02/25/2019 Brezhnev’s new heir is homeless in Turkey
02/26/2019 The Brezhnev-Milaev clan finds out the truth
02/27/2019 A young mother left her three-year-old daughter to die
28.02.2019 World star looking for relatives from the USSR
03/04/2019 The grandson of Spartak Mishulin wants to receive an inheritance
03/05/2019 Scandal in the family of Margarita Terekhova
03/06/2019 Who does Alexander Serov lead to the altar
03/11/2019 In memory of Vladimir Etush
03/12/2019 (1) Girl-Mowgli
03/12/2019 (2) Girl-Mowgli
03.13.2019 (3) Girl-Mowgli
03/14/2019 The secret of Sergei Filippov’s will
03/18/2019 Another illegitimate child of Alexander Nikulin
03/18/2019 The heart of a star: the happiness and tragedy of Yulia Nachalova
03/19/2019 The last will of Yulia Nachalova
03/20/2019 Who framed the Mowgli girl’s mother
03/21/2019 The last secret of Yulia Nachalova
03/25/2019 Where is Valery Zolotukhin’s secret lover now?
03/26/2019 Efim Shifrin about vision loss
03/27/2019 Alexander Frolov about Yulia Nachalova
03/28/2019 The son of actor Vadim Andreev beats his wife
04/01/2019 From whom is Lyudmila Gurchenko’s granddaughter seeking protection?
04/02/2019 Three fathers of two children
04/03/2019 Special homework: two years in slavery to a school teacher?
04/04/2019 Where did Ivan Novoseltsev go?
04/08/2019 Fight for property in star families
04/09/2019 The family of Nonna Mordyukova is once again shaken by scandal
04/10/2019 Will of Alexey Buldakov
11.04.2019 Bastard Alexandra Nikulina
04/15/2019 Alla Pugacheva and her closest ones
04/16/2019 What threatens a mother of two children
04/17/2019 Lidiya Fedoseeva Shukshina
04/18/2019 Lydia meets with rejected daughters
04/22/2019 Who is hunting for the inheritance of Nikolai Prokopovich?
23.04.2019 New round conflict between the heirs of Nikolai Prokopovich
04/24/2019 10 DNA tests for those confused in the maternity hospital
04/25/2019 Tatyana Vasilyeva about the death of Irina Tsyvina
04/29/2019 Two beloved women of Dmitry Maryanov
04/30/2019 The unknown love of Dmitry Maryanov
05/06/2019 The son of Yuri Belov was expelled from the family and lives on the street
05/06/2019 Tragedy at Sheremetyevo
05/07/2019 Donors for Wehrmarcht soldiers
05/13/2019 Life and death in the oncoming lane.
05/14/2019 Illegitimate children of a famous artist share the inheritance during their father’s lifetime
05/15/2019 Beloved niece of Zykina. The curse of diamonds or a life of poverty?
16.05.2019 Secret wedding: Why wasn’t Alexander Serov at his daughter’s party?
05.20.2019 Zykina’s earrings
05/21/2019 DNA as salvation: terminally ill daughter searches for mother
05/22/2019 Shpalikov’s will: the daughter of the screenwriter “I’m Walking Around Moscow” asks for help
05/23/2019 Secret video star wedding: Alexander Serov finally married his daughter
05.27.2019 All about the great daughter: Lyubov Polishchuk’s mother breaks the silence
05/28/2019 Family detective with child abduction
05/29/2019 Good deed or scam? The new owner of the star's inheritance comes out of the shadows
05/30/2019 Without money and housing: the son of a national artist is expelled from his family and lives on the street
06/03/2019 What Alexander Belyavsky hid even from his loved ones
06/04/2019 Secret children of the People's Artist: results of a series of DNA tests
06/05/2019 A famous journalist is afraid of his young wife
06/06/2019 Duel of descendants
06/10/2019 Tragedy of Bari Alibasov
06/11/2019 This is not a mirage
06/13/2019 Babies in the pool are like in a washing machine
06/17/2019 Mister X: The secret son of Sergei Zakharov
06/17/2019 Kidnapping of Bari Alibasov
06/18/2019 Mister X: The secret son of Sergei Zakharov
06/19/2019 Did Juna pass off someone else’s child as her own?
06/20/2019 Confrontation: the main heiress of diamonds, Zykina, meets with her relatives
Screenshot from YouTube / channel "Let them talk"
In one of them it turns out that the mother who raised her stepdaughter was confused more than half a century ago.
On January 30, the studio of the popular Russian talk show “Let Them Talk” filmed a program about the substitution of children in a maternity hospital in the Kurumkansky district. It will presumably air on Tuesday, February 7th. During the investigation of the 34-year-old story, Moscow journalists revealed new details, so there will be two issues. In the second, they will talk about the details of the replacement of children in the same maternity hospital, but which occurred more than half a century ago.
Switched children
Let us recall that in one of latest numbers newspaper "Inform Policy" (dated January 18 this year), a journalist from the publication spoke about what happened 34 years ago. On the same day, January 21, 1983, two girls were born here, within a few hours of each other. For almost 15 years, there was speculation that none of them looked like their mother. A genetic examination carried out at the Center for Molecular Genetics (CMG) in Moscow put an end to this issue. The initiators of the DNA analysis were Alisa Tsyrenova and her daughter Yulia, who live in Ulan-Ude.
Ironically, the second woman who gave birth on January 21, 1983 was Alisa Tsyrenova’s namesake - Lyubov Tsyrenova from the village of Bulak, Kurumkansky district. Dugarma became the third child in the family of Lyubov and Dasha Tsyrenov. Many found similarities between Dugarma and the Baikal Theater artist Alisa Tsyrenova. And about Yulia, who was still in her third year at the Belarusian State Agricultural Academy, did an internship in the village of Maysk, they said that she looked like the children of Lyubov and Dasha Tsyrenov from the village of Bulak.
The mothers of two girls tried to understand whether a substitution could have occurred in the maternity hospital. They found out that Alice gave birth to a girl weighing 3300 grams, and Lyubov - 2900. And the fact that one girl lost several grams upon discharge, and the other, on the contrary, gained, did not bother the women - this is a normal phenomenon for newborns.
Conversations about a possible substitution of children intensified when Dugarma Tsyrenova began working in the cultural sector of the region. She took part in song competitions, became a songwriter on Buryat language and even released a disc.
On December 12, 2016, Alisa Tsyrenova and her daughter Yulia decided to take a responsible step - taking a DNA test in one of medical centers Ulan-Ude. From there, the biological materials of mother and daughter were sent to Moscow. And exactly a month later, on January 12, 2017, a response came from the Center for Molecular Genetics, where it was written in black and white: “Tsyrenova Alisa Ayusheevna is not the biological mother of Tsyrenova Yulia Alekseevna.”
We chose “Let them talk”
The story of child switching interested federal journalists. From the program “Let Them Talk” they called Alisa Tsyrenova. At the same time, they called from the program “Male/Female,” which also airs on Channel One. But two Tsyrenov families chose the program of Andrei Malakhov. Late in the evening of January 26, journalists from Moscow arrived in Ulan-Ude. They say that first they flew to Irkutsk, and from there they took a taxi to the capital of the republic and stayed at the Buryatia hotel. On January 27, they took the same taxi to the village of Bulak, Kurumkansky district, where the spouses Lyubov and Dashi Tsyrenov live. It is not known whether Channel One journalists were able to talk with the medical staff of the Kurumkan Central District Hospital, where the child swap took place 34 years ago. According to unconfirmed reports, the doctors refused to make any comments. That same evening, Moscow journalists, Lyubov and Dugarma, left for Ulan-Ude together.
On January 28, in the morning there was filming with Alisa Tsyrenova, and in the afternoon with the family of her daughter Yulia, who lives in the Shishkovka area.
On January 29, 11 people flew from Ulan-Ude to the Russian capital to film the program “Let Them Talk.” This is Alisa Tsyrenova and her daughter Yulia with their youngest, eight-month-old son. The Kurumkan family was introduced by Lyubov Tsyrenova and her daughters Dugarma and Natalya, who is said to look like Yulia. Alisa’s support group included her friend Larisa Orkhokova, classmate Tsytsygma Angabaeva, with whom Dugarma lived in the village of Mogoito, Kurumkansky district, when she graduated from school, as well as Yulia’s paternal aunt Galina.
And mom was replaced!
During Alisa Tsyrenova’s negotiations with representatives of “Let Them Talk,” it turned out that she herself might have been replaced in the maternity hospital 56 years ago. She herself is from the village of Shamanka, born on December 18, 1960, and Butidma was born on December 17 and grew up in Argada.
As a result, Butidma and her sister Tatyana, as well as Seseg from the Tsyrenov family, where Alisa grew up, took part in the “Let Them Talk” program. In Moscow, they underwent a genetic examination, which showed that Alisa and Tatyana are sisters, and Butidma and Seseg are also blood. This incredible story, which happened to Alisa, who herself was replaced in the maternity hospital 56 years ago, and her daughter 34 years ago, so shocked the team of the “Let Them Talk” program that they decided to devote two programs to her. The first - about the story of Alice and Lyubov and their daughters Yulia and Dugarme - will be shown on Channel One, presumably on February 7, and on February 8 they will talk about the second story.
Non-disclosure agreement
As the site's correspondent learned, Leonid Turbyanov, a deputy of the People's Khural of the Republic of Belarus from the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, a former official in the Potapov government, took part in the filming on Channel One as an expert. Participants in the talk show have not yet commented on the details of the filming, arguing that they signed a non-disclosure agreement. One of the participants in the filming, on condition of anonymity, only admitted that it was amazing; those sitting in the audience liked the way the people from Buryatia behaved in the studio. There were no usual hysterics and scandals, which is what many people associate with the “Let Them Talk” program.
She also added that there was a small dispute between Leonid Turbyanov and one of the experts, a Moscow guest. The second did not like the deputy’s opinion that child swapping had happened before and there was nothing wrong with it. We will see what really happened there on February 7 and 8.
Yulia Belyaeva, the mother of one of them, and Naimat Iskanderov, the father of the other, received compensation from the maternity hospital. It seemed that everything was behind us. However, now Julia wants both girls to be with her. Naimat is seeking the same thing. This means that children will face new shocks. Exactly the same story happened 35 years ago in Perm region. However, families there behaved differently. Because it was in their souls more love than anger.
Everyone here has known everything for a long time and believes that things are different normal people and it cannot be, even if this story began completely abnormally.
By malicious intent
The children were replaced in the maternity hospital. This happened in the regional medical unit, in the village of Uinskoye, Perm Region, on August 6, 1976. The boys were born one after another. But it would hardly be possible to confuse them by accident. The nurse deliberately brought the black-haired, dark-skinned baby to the blue-eyed blonde Gala, while his mother was recovering from difficult birth. Two days later, the blond boy born by Galina waited for his first natural feeding, but he was not given the breast. dear mother, and black-eyed Yazilya. Both women gave birth to their first children. We were glad that the children were healthy. We had no complaints about hair or eye color.
What about the nurse? Later, out of drunkenness, she confessed: she had staged a prank, she wanted to see what would happen. By the way, my sister showed up for that duty fairly drunk after someone’s regular name day. The drunkard didn’t have a chance to see “what would happen”: she didn’t live to see the outcome of the events.
When Galina Plotnikova brought her son home, her mother-in-law said abruptly:
- Not our child! We won't be born like that. All the ones I had were white. And this one...
And yet Andreika, growing up, melted his grandmother’s heart. Affectionate, hard-working, agile, he became the most beloved of the grandchildren. Grandmother even remembered: they say that there were brunettes in the Plotnikov family, even if not in a straight line, but it was passed on, apparently, through genes. Biology is a dark science.
The Kalimovs also “guessed” where the blond boy came from: the great-uncle was unmistakably recognizable in the features of the growing Damir - the same gait, the same habits.
... Rumors about hospital crimes spread throughout the area, but the Kalimovs did not take them personally, and the Plotnikovs soon moved to another area...
Yazilya learned the truth when Damir was three years old. How? From whom? She was silent then and doesn’t speak now. I decided this: children should not be traumatized, let the sons grow up first. When they return from the army, they will find out the truth. She didn’t know that Galina was tormented by the same doubts. The boys grew up and became more and more like their fathers. Rumors began to spread again. One day, Galina’s relative came from Uinsky and said: I saw your husband Pavel there, only a young man. How can it be?
- It seemed! - Galina answered, and her heart sank.
In a single family
In the Permian south, Russians, Tatars, Bashkirs, and Maris have lived side by side for more than 500 years. In some Semyonovka, the predominantly Tatar population may have an effect. The Plotnikovs, on the contrary, lived among only Russians in a village with the Turkic name Suda, where everyone called Andrei “Tatar.” The boy was very angry about this. He defended his Russianness with the fervor of Mowgli, who wanted to prove to everyone that he was a real wolf. Time passed, and school nicknames lost their relevance. In 1994, Andrei received a summons to the army. It was not a good year for conscription; the “first Chechen war” began. But Andrei was lucky in the war - he returned alive. Probably because two mothers prayed for him at once.
I'm sitting with the Kalimovs. Papa Mansor is tired of the children’s story, he doesn’t want to talk about it, but Yazil’s mother explains again and again that the boys are lucky: they now have many relatives and many parents...
You're sorry that Andrey didn't receive higher education, you learned Damir at the institute? - I ask.
It's his choice. If he doesn’t want to study, you can’t force him,” Yazilya answers. She and Mansor have no complaints, no comments about how the Plotnikovs raised their son.
Each language has its own designations for the degree of relationship: daughter-in-law, brother-in-law, cousin, matchmakers, godfathers... How the Plotnikovs and Kalimovs are related to each other cannot be said either in Russian or in Tatar: there is no such word. How to determine the existing relationship? Very simply - they are flawless.
15 years later
They end exactly at the moment when families are reunited. Nobody knows how to live further. Now the tears of happiness have dried up, and every day you have to call me mom unknown woman, and my own mother suddenly turns out to be not my own at all... The Perm film studio undertook to film documentary about what happens “later”, timed the expedition to Uinskoye to coincide with the twenty-fifth birthday of Damir and Andrey. According to the scenario, two families gather for a holiday. The heroes of the uninvented plot have already experienced the shock and have found a way to open their inner circle to new parents and numerous new relatives. It was not easy to convince them to talk on camera about their feelings. Galina and Andrey were against it, but Yazilya had the final say. She sensibly decided that it was worth showing people how grief can turn into happiness if there is more love in a person’s soul than anger.
It was easier for Galina and I,” says Yazilya. - We knew for a long time. The news of the substitution shocked the family. It was especially difficult for Andrey. We prepared Damir, and I gradually brought the younger children and sisters up to speed. But Andrei accidentally overheard the conversation and understood. He was in pain.
After the documentary, people stopped gossiping about the Kalimovs and Plotnikovs. Burning interest gave way to deep respect. It seemed that everything was behind us. And thanks to the story of girls from the Chelyabinsk region, the topic became hot again.
They ask why we don’t file a claim for compensation, they say, they sued for three million. And who should we demand from, the district hospital? What you have experienced cannot be repaid with money. And we have nothing to complain about,” says Yazilya.
The Kalimovs and Plotnikovs are now together forever, because there is no way for them to separate either their eldest sons or their grandchildren. The two women understand and support each other from the very day when Yazilya went 80 kilometers to the village where Galina lives, without even knowing the exact address. I just decided it was time. On the way, she got caught in the rain and entered the Plotnikovs’ house wet. Galina looked and understood everything - who she was, why. Without saying a word, they cried, hugged each other, and then looked at a family album with photographs of their son for a long time.
They don't want to talk about it anymore because they've already told everything. They live on. And they are happy.
The photo shows stills from the film “Two Sons of Yazili Kalimova.” Dir. P. Pechenkin.
Loading...
